The latest craze these days seems to be making a deal or a
contract with your kid to get the expected behavior out of them. Recently, a mom blogged her “contract” with
her 13 year old son—a contract she wrote to coincide with giving him an iPhone
for Christmas.
The contract, written by
Janell Burley Hofmann, is seen here: http://www.janellburleyhofmann.com/gregorys-iphone-contract/
It’s an amusing read, I agree. But I sincerely hope she wrote this for the
sake of good writing, and not for the sake of having a binding agreement with
her 13 year old CHILD.
My thoughts?
First—what 13 year old child needs a Smart Phone?? My husband doesn’t even have one, and he’s a
successful man in the business world. He
can still talk and text from his phone, but one does not need access to
Facebook or Google at one’s fingertips at all times. Especially a 13 year old. You’re one lucky kid, Gregory. Your parents not only shelled out a couple
hundred dollars to secure you a sweet new phone, but they’ll be paying a good
solid $40-70 per month in addition just to make it function.
We did purchase a phone for our oldest child for her 13th
birthday. We even set some ground
rules—the first being that she has to pay her monthly bill on her own. We bought the phone for her, and gifted her 3
months of her payment. She had to have 6
months worth of payments already saved up before we’d consider it. She has to pay $15 per month to keep the
phone--$10 covers our add-a-line, and $5 covers a percentage of our monthly
unlimited texting, of which she takes full advantage.
Initially, we told her she only had 250 texts – incoming and
outgoing – per month. We didn’t tell her
until month four that she has unlimited.
Why? What cruel parent would do
that, you ask? Well, it helped set the
standard from the start that she needs to still remember how to communicate
verbally with people, and that she shouldn’t have her phone in her hand at all
times. By month four, her habit was
formed. She does text more than that
now, but she still keeps it to a minimum.
We’ve taken the phone away before—not for violating a
contract, but because we are parents and feel it is our duty to punish an
unreasonable act of behavior or other activity by a punishment we feel
fits. Sometimes that may mean no
phone. Sometimes that may mean no outing
with friends. Sometimes that means she
has to go to bed when her little siblings do. Mean?
No. Parental? Yes.
By no means am I saying the author of the above contract is wrong to do that--we all parent differently--but I do think it warrants a second thought.